Steam Monopoly Lawsuit Attorney

U.S. District Court Judge John C. Coughenour ruled that Valve Corporation, the publisher of Steam, a PC gaming platform and digital sales store, should face antitrust litigation. Coughenour handed down the decision on May 6. He offered his opinion on the matter, saying Valve is in a favorable position in the market and can use its dominance to intimidate or exploit customers and developers.

The ruling included information about the company’s alleged actions. The judge wrote that Valve allegedly engages in unlawful conduct by enforcing unwritten and written rules regarding game pricing and sales. The company imposes conditions on how publishers and other market participants can price and sell even non-Steam-enabled games.

About Valve and Steam

Valve is the premier gaming platform in the United States and the world. Valve began as a video game development company but shifted its business when it created the Steam platform. Steam was meant to focus on patching and updating bugs in games. Over time, Steam shifted its business from a patching and version control service by adding an online store where games could be purchased. Any game purchased through Steam couldn’t be played unless the user had or created an account with the Steam platform.

Steam eventually acquired a blockbuster hit from another multi-player service that was forced to shut down. When Steam acquired that game and required its users to open Steam accounts to play it, they were able to force their gaming platform on a greater portion of the market. There are at least 50,000 games on Steam, and most of them are third-party creations.

Wolfire Games Founder Seeks Legal Action

David Rosen, the founder of Wolfire Games, claimed he had no choice but to pursue a lawsuit against Valve. He alleged the Steam creator company interfered with other storefronts’ pricing and took inordinate cuts of revenue from other developers. Rosen decided to file an antitrust lawsuit accusing the company of using Steam to create a monopoly on the distribution of PC games.

Rosen also expanded on his allegations, claiming his company personally experienced the misconduct outlined in the complaint. New video game stores that charged lower commissions than Valve prompted his decision to provide his game Overgrowth at a lower price. He wanted to take advantage of the lower commission rates. He also intended to blog about the results of his decision.

However, after discussing his plan with Steam, the company responded with threats of removing Overgrowth from Steam if Wolfire Games sold the game at a lower price anywhere else, including on its own website, without using Steam’s DRM and keys. Steam keys enable the user to access a game on the Steam platform, and can be sold by other platforms.

Rosen also brought accusations against Valve, claiming the company threatened other developers that charged lower prices on competing storefronts. The threats involved removing titles from Steam if the developers didn’t increase pricing. According to Rosen, determining whether Steam or any other game developer earns a commission is impossible.

Did Valve Corp. Violate Antitrust Law?

Antitrust laws exist on the federal level, and some states have their own antitrust laws. In the United States, the primary federal antitrust law is the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890. This law prohibits any agreement that restrains trade, including monopolization and attempts to monopolize, price fixing, and other anti-competitive practices.

Rosen contacted a legal expert after his own experience with Valve and learning about other developers’ experiences. He wanted to know if the company followed antitrust law.

That is when he decided to file a lawsuit. He thinks most developers fear losing most of their revenue if they don’t sell on Valve’s digital store since a majority of their sales come from that platform. Game development is already risky, and avoiding Steam altogether would add unnecessary additional risk. That is why many developers don’t have much choice other than to sell their products on Steam and follow Valve’s orders.

Efforts to Make the Lawsuit Go Away

After Rosen filed his lawsuit, Valve fought back by filing a motion to dismiss. In the motion, Valve claims the lawsuit only has one factual allegation. That involves Valve allegedly informing one unnamed developer not to provide a non-Steam-enabled game for free on Discord’s competing platform if it charges $5 to use the Steam-enabled version of the game on the Steam platform.

However, the evidence does not support Rosen’s allegations of other developers receiving threats of their games getting pulled from the platform. He explained how Wolfire experienced those threats, but he only believed others experienced the same threats. He didn’t provide anecdotes or evidence to back up those claims.

Valve also mentions its rights to price match a game’s Steam listing with Steam Keys sold on other platforms. It directly negates the language in Rosen’s complaint, alleging that under antitrust law, Valve doesn’t have a duty to allow developers to undersell prices for games sold on Steam using free Steam Keys.

The rest of the motion explained why Steam justifies taking a 30 percent cut of sales, considering its position in the PC video game business.

Court Ruling on Steam Lawsuits

At first, District Judge Coughenour preliminarily ruled in favor of Valve’s motion to dismiss. He partly dismissed the case. He also requested arbitration for all consumer claims.

However, Coughenour allowed Wolfire to file another lawsuit regarding issues he mentioned in his dismissal order. As a result, Rosen decided to proceed with another claim, arguing that Steam operates as a store and gaming platform in two separate markets. He believes Valve should not be allowed to combine the two.

The judge disagreed. He said consumer demand for a fully functional gaming platform separate from a digital store does not exist. He dismissed that claim but allowed the rest of the lawsuit focusing on Valve’s alleged control of sales and pricing, to proceed in the district court.

Let Attorney Tom Help You Fight for Justice

If you suffered losses due to Valve’s alleged illegal monopoly in the PC gaming marketplace, do not hesitate to call the antitrust lawsuit attorneys of Attorney Tom at (713) 244-6363 for a confidential consultation. We will fight to try to achieve a favorable outcome. You can count on our legal team to protect your rights and aggressively pursue the compensation you deserve.


I was very satisfied with the outcome of my settlement.

I was very satisfied with the outcome of my settlement. I would strongly recommend this firm they are 100% in my book.

Posted By:

Carmen Malbrough

When my girlfriend was in a pretty bad car accident, I...

When my girlfriend was in a pretty bad car accident, I was fortunate enough to know Tommy from my personal life. We reached out to Tommy and in no time...

Posted By:

Monkmonk Dabes

If you are here, you’re likely searching for an attorney. Well,...

If you are here, you’re likely searching for an attorney. Well, stop searching. Our home was totaled in Hurricane Laura, and unknowingly we not being treated fairly by another party....

Posted By:

Eva Atwell

Hi hired Tom to handle my personal injury case. I was...

Hi hired Tom to handle my personal injury case. I was hit by an 18-wheeler and we got a GREAT result. I recommend hiring Attorney Tom and his team to...

Posted By:


I contacted the firm and spoke directly to Tommy who was...

I contacted the firm and spoke directly to Tommy who was very professional and responsive to all of our concerns and assured me that we had a great case, we...

Posted By:

Wayne Dore

Attorney Tom and his team went above and beyond to resolve...

Attorney Tom and his team went above and beyond to resolve our case. They treated us with empathy, respect, and professionalism. He is a great attorney and worked diligently for...

Posted By:

Angela O’Quain

Tom and his team are truly top notch. They go above...

Tom and his team are truly top notch. They go above and beyond in every way imaginable and most importantly, they treated me like a real person and not just...

Posted By:

Jerry McElroy

Attorney Tom is the best in the business! Extremely knowledgeable, very...

Attorney Tom is the best in the business! Extremely knowledgeable, very professional, and will always fight for you to the ends of the world! His team is very communicative and...

Posted By:

Christopher Torres

In my many occasions working with Attorney Tom and his staff,...

In my many occasions working with Attorney Tom and his staff, it has been nothing but a pleasant experience. I hold Attorney Tom and and all of his staff in...

Posted By:

William Beard

Very professional and responsive

I told him Tommy John, you’re my hero. Because that’s how I feel about him. I do not know what I would have done without Tommy John and his team....

Posted By:

Jarrett R.

Thomas John Kherkher is a great choice for legal representation

Thomas John Kherker was extremely professional when dealing with my case. I had gotten into a tough spot involving contracts and was entirely taken advantage of. Thomas was recommended to...

Posted By:


When I was rear ended they had my back.

Mr. Kherkher and his team represented me in a highway accident that resulted in my car being totaled. These are some of the things I appreciated the most during our...

Posted By:


They are very organized

The team at The Kherkher Law Firm are polite and will work hard for you. They are very organized. I would definitely recommend going to them for your personal injury...

Posted By:

Jarrett Richter

Very friendly and responsive

Kherkher Law is the best. Very friendly and responsive. Helped me work through my issue.

Posted By:

Mike Johnson

Tommy was very kind and helpful

Attorney Tommy was very kind and helpful and he has a great YouTube channel @attorneytom I feel comfortable going to him for any of my future legal concerns.

Posted By:

Alex Cardenas

immediately answered the phone on a Saturday at 4:35pm

While mistakenly detained by the police I called attorney Tommy Kherkher who immediately answered the phone on a Saturday at 4:35pm today 6/1/19 and was quickly released. It was happy...

Posted By:

Therrion Reff

integrity and honor

A person of integrity and honor. He will work hard for you.

Posted By:

Susan Kherkher

He is among the best

I have known Tommy John Kherkher for a long time. He is among the best. A true lawyer and extremely responsive.

Posted By:

Cody Hall

NBC News
buzzfeed logo
fortune logo
yahoo finance logo
khou logo
time logo